5-Formula BMR Comparison Tool
Compare your Basal Metabolic Rate across five major peer-reviewed equations: Mifflin-St Jeor, Revised Harris-Benedict, Cunningham, Katch-McArdle, and Oxford/Henry.
Your Profile
Enter your age, weight and height
The formulas compare side by side as you type. Add a body fat percentage to include the two lean-mass formulas.
Ready to turn this into a structured plan?
Use our Katch-McArdle tool with lean body mass partitioning or reverse diet planner.
Understanding the 5 Major Metabolic Equations
No single equation is universally perfect for every human body. Each formula was derived from specific demographic cohorts, clinical conditions, and measurement methodologies:
1. Mifflin-St Jeor (1990)
General Gold StandardDeveloped by MD Mifflin and ST St Jeor at the University of Nevada School of Medicine. Evaluated in 498 healthy individuals across varying body compositions. Extensively validated by the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics as the most accurate equation for the general adult population, with 82% of estimates falling within ±10% of indirect calorimetry.
2. Cunningham (1980)
Athletic Gold StandardPublished in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. JJ Cunningham indexed resting metabolic rate strictly to fat-free mass (FFM). Highly recommended by the International Society of Sports Nutrition (ISSN) for athletes, powerlifters, and bodybuilders because lean mass accounts for over 85% of resting energy variance.
3. Katch-McArdle (1996)
Body Fat Specific
Derived from exercise physiology testing by Frank Katch and William McArdle. Like Cunningham, it eliminates gender and height coefficients, calculating energy directly as 370 + 21.6 × LBM (kg). Exceptional precision for individuals with known body fat percentages between 6% and 30%.
4. Revised Harris-Benedict (Roza & Shizgal 1984)
Historical ClinicalThe original 1919 Carnegie Institution benchmark was updated in 1984 by Roza and Shizgal using modern mathematical re-evaluation. While historically ubiquitous in hospital inpatient settings, it generally overpredicts calorie expenditure in modern sedentary populations compared to Mifflin-St Jeor.
5. Oxford / Henry (2005)
Age-Bracketed StandardCreated by Professor C.J.K. Henry of Oxford Brookes University on behalf of the UK Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN). Replaces the 1985 Schofield/WHO database, which was artificially skewed by disproportionately athletic Italian military recruits. Provides segmented linear equations per age bracket.
Head-to-Head Comparison Matrix
| Formula | Inputs Required | Lean Mass vs Total Weight | Typical Bias / Tendency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mifflin-St Jeor | Weight, Height, Age, Sex | Total Weight | Balanced; within ±10% for 82% of adults. |
| Cunningham | Weight + Body Fat % (LBM) | Lean Mass Only | Higher for athletes; reflects high muscle metabolic cost. |
| Katch-McArdle | Weight + Body Fat % (LBM) | Lean Mass Only | Slightly more conservative than Cunningham; highly accurate. |
| Harris-Benedict | Weight, Height, Age, Sex | Total Weight | Runs +3% to +7% higher than Mifflin. |
| Oxford / Henry | Weight, Age, Sex | Total Weight | Optimal for elderly and international cohort comparisons. |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which BMR formula is the most accurate?
For the general population with average body composition, the Mifflin-St Jeor formula is considered the most clinically accurate and is endorsed by the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. For resistance-trained athletes, bodybuilders, or individuals who know their body fat percentage, the Cunningham (1980) and Katch-McArdle (1996) formulas are superior because they calculate energy expenditure directly from Lean Body Mass.
How does Cunningham differ from Mifflin-St Jeor?
Mifflin-St Jeor relies on total body weight, height, age, and sex, assuming standard metabolic tissue ratios. In contrast, Cunningham uses only Lean Body Mass (BMR = 500 + 22 × LBM in kg). Because lean muscle burns significantly more energy than adipose tissue, Cunningham provides much higher, more realistic calorie targets for muscular individuals.
Why does Harris-Benedict estimate a higher BMR than Mifflin-St Jeor?
The original 1919 Harris-Benedict equation systematically overestimated metabolic rates by 5% to 15% due to older laboratory indirect calorimetry methodologies and non-diverse cohorts. While Roza and Shizgal revised it in 1984, it still tends to predict higher caloric needs than modern formulas.
What is the Oxford / Henry equation?
Published in 2005 by Professor C.J.K. Henry, the Oxford equations analyze modern worldwide datasets while excluding the heavily skewed Italian cohort of earlier Schofield/WHO studies. It uses age-bracketed multipliers and is widely adopted across the UK and international clinical nutrition.
How much variance is normal between different BMR formulas?
A spread of 100 to 250 kcal/day between the 5 major formulas is completely normal. Equations indexing total weight (Mifflin, Harris-Benedict) diverge from lean-mass equations (Cunningham, Katch-McArdle) as a person's body composition moves further away from the demographic average.